To refer to the hr analogy, it is like herzbergs hygiene motivation theory which recommends building motivation factors in a job or mc gregors x and y theory which talks about a leaders attitude towards his reportees. Chan kim is the codirector of the insead blue ocean strategy institute and a chair professor of. This is the only use the critics who view five forces analysis as completely static have acknowledged. Hence in essence, the organization creates its own new market and if.
Five forces analysis can be used to claim new strategic positions in times of change. The concept of blue ocean strategies is new in the business world as it was first published in 2005 in the bookmanual blue ocean strategy, by w. The authors suggest a blend of blue ocean vs five forces the case centre, for educators. This allows them to build a viable business model and ensure that a company profits from the blue ocean it is creating. In their 2017 new york times bestselling book, blue ocean shift, kim and mauborgne share how to put these practical marketcreating tools into practice to move from red to blue oceans and to do so in a way that people own and drive the process. Michael porters five forces strategy before going to compare blue ocean strategy and porters five forces strategy, let us get a better understanding of what these strategies actually are. Blue ocean strategy is a business strategy book, first published on february 3, 2005 by the harvard business school press. Factors such as competitive rivalry, new entrants, buyer power, supplier power, and threat of substitution are factors which when conquered would not necessarily make you as a market leader since one of the criticism of this model is that businesses are not always in a web while blue ocean strategy is a strategy that is undertaken by an organization in a new dimension in which its competitors havent ventured into. Porters five forces model, blue ocean strategy and. In the integrated approach to strategy at the system level, blue ocean strategy requires organization to develop and align the three strategy proposition. Walmart porters five forces analysis researchmethodology. Five forces analysis can be used to choose the position of the company in the industry. In this article, we will look at 1 what is a blue ocean strategy. Porters five forces model looks at the current market and allows the company.
Chan kim and renee mauborgne, professors at insead and codirectors of the insead blue ocean strategy institute. Porter s five forces model versus a blue ocean strategy. This blog article is a overview of some of the key points of the book by w. Looking at entire industries in this way allows you to tell over time whether an innovation strategy or a competitive strategy is best. Attractiveness in this context refers to the overall industry profitability. Mar 22, 2020 porters 5 forces examines the five forces that make a company competitive while helping identify its strengths and weaknesses. This part of the five forces analysis shows that apple must maintain its competitive advantage through innovation and marketing to remain strong against new entrants moderate competitive force. To be sum it up, porters five forces model is a common or a general model that conceptualizes the understanding of strategy. One of the most successful efforts to do so is the book blue ocean strategy, by w. It takesoff from the five forces model as the launchpad or lets says its on the starting line. Strategy as a business function will always be relevant and so will be porters book. Porters five forces model is an analytical framework for assessing business competitiveness strategies in a particular market.
Blue ocean strategy including examples and pdf download. Apr 26, 2012 now, i would like to emphasize the difference between porters five forces and blue ocean strategy for a deeper understanding of what it is all about. What is the blue ocean strategy the term blue ocean was coined by two professors w. Each industry underwent continuous upheaval, each time spurred by a blue ocean strategy that 1 reduced factors unimportant to buyers, 2 increased factors important to buyers, 3 expanded the market. The authors conclude that the blueocean strategy or innovation approach is sustainable. Michael porters five forces strategy your full full may 11, blue ocean strategy vs. But, lets first understand what is blue ocean and how it is different from red ocean strategy. It is about creating and capturing uncontested market space, thereby making the competition irrelevant. Business strategy from michael porter to blue oceans to.
Blue ocean strategies bos denote strategies that result in the creation of new markets. Chan kim and renee mauborgne, professors at insead. Fortunately, i found out that they think its a battle of which of the two strategies is the most effective way in the industry. Why do business people always compare porters five forces and blue ocean strategy. They assert that these strategic moves create a leap in value for the company, its buyers, and its employees while unlocking new demand and making the competition irrelevant. Porters model is based on the insight that a corporate strategy should meet the opportunities and threats in the organizations external environment. Blue ocean strategy is the simultaneous pursuit of differentiation and low cost to open up a new market space and create new demand. Jul 16, 2015 the blue ocean strategy is a reconstructionist view of the market where no accepted boundaries or structure is present. It views longterm competition as the main concern that business people should be. There are many ideas floating out there about what makes a business successful and how to remain successful. Blue ocean strategy can be applied across sectors or businesses. Its not better its just different porter five forces model is used to understand the dynamics of an industry while blue ocean is a specific strategy choice a company can pursue. Porters 5 forces examines the five forces that make a company competitive while helping identify its strengths and weaknesses. Porter model vs blue ocean strategy best practices.
Marketing was and will be the creation of differentiated, targeted value simila. It draws upon industrial organization io economics to derive five forces that determine the competitive intensity and therefore attractiveness of amarket. The elimination reduction improvement creation net 4. Porters model looks at specific factors that help determine whether a business. Aug 25, 2016 professor joe tidd identifies the weaknesses of the traditional five forces approach to strategy, and the advantages of adopting a blue ocean strategy. Core strategy tools 7 focusing on the positives and opening up opportunities. The economist a great read for any leader looking to get a real edge in business and establish a real competitive advantage in the market. Oct 26, 2010 the blue ocean strategy on the other hand is purely a strategy. His book blue ocean strategy, coauthored with renee mauborgne, has sold 3. Michael porters five forces strategy before going to compare blue ocean strategy and porters five forces strategy, let us get a better understanding of. Red oceans represent markets where incumbents red ocean strategies ros are fairly similar and rivals are battling over a shrinking profit pool.
All the data that i collected are from relevant sources that can be verified which strengthen the validity of my thesis. The premise of the book is that companies can succeed by creating. Blue ocean vs five forces the case centre, for educators. Professor joe tidd identifies the weaknesses of the traditional five forces approach to strategy, and the advantages of adopting a blue ocean strategy. Add a comment below to participate in the discussion, ask a new question or search our archives of over 45,900 questions and 278,800 answers posted in knowhow exchange since january 2004. Apr 27, 2012 in the integrated approach to strategy at the system level, blue ocean strategy requires organization to develop and align the three strategy proposition. Blue ocean strategy challenges companies to break out of the red ocean of bloody competition by creating uncontested market space that makes the competition irrelevant. Blue ocean strategy is a book published in 2005 and written by w. What makes blue ocean strategy better than porters five.
After almost fifteen years, the idea of creating a blue ocean strategy is still very popular. At heart, strategy is about managing value something central to business. Blue ocean strategy is a marketing theory and the title of a book published in 2004 that was written by w. It is based on the view that market boundaries and industry structure are not a given and can be. Instead of dividing up existingand often shrinkingdemand and benchmarking competitors, blue ocean strategy is about growing demand and breaking. Question 14 20 pts discuss the importance of evidencebased e. Porters five forces is a very competitive marketing strategy. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of each strategy within your comparison.
Business strategy from michael porter to blue oceans to what. By that we can see that there is a lot of interest by the business people and academics around the world about that subject. A blue ocean, as used in the title of this book and strategy, is basically uncharted territory in the business world. Porters five forces model versus a blue ocean strategy porters five forces model, provided by michael porter, is an external environmental analysis tool for a specific market this model emphasizes that in any existing industry, there are five competition forces. Theory and evidence, examined the dutch retail industry during. If blue ocean strategy dominates in the shortterm while porters five forces dominates in the longterm such that profits are positively related to the number of firms in the shortterm but negatively related in the longterm, that would imply that innovation by new firms generates shortterm competitive advantage with associated higher profits but through imitation and simultaneous competition the longterm effect of an increased number of firms would result to lesser profitability. The structure can be created or recreated by the steps taken by players in the market. Blue ocean strategy business model blue ocean tools and. Blue ocean strategy blue ocean strategy is a business strategy book published in 2005 by harvard business school publishing corporation in united state of america, it was written by w. Apr 27, 2012 it is argued that rather than a theory, blue ocean strategy is an extremely successful attempt to brand a set of already existing concepts and frameworks with a highly sticky idea. Apr 27, 2012 if blue ocean strategy dominates in the shortterm while porters five forces dominates in the longterm such that profits are positively related to the number of firms in the shortterm but negatively related in the longterm, that would imply that innovation by new firms generates shortterm competitive advantage with associated higher.
Strategy and thinking is not limited by preconceived barriers, and a shift happens from a focus on the supply side to a focus on the demand. Recognized as one of the most iconic and impactful strategy books ever written, blue ocean strategy argues that cutthroat competition results in nothing but a bloody red ocean of rivals fighting over a shrinking profit pool. Technological environment the broad porters industry analysis five forces model competitive industry life cycle company analysis see section on. Chan kim and renee mauborgne have created a comprehensive set of analytic tools and frameworks to create blue oceans of new market space. Student questions blue ocean strategy vs porters generic. Business strategy from michael porter to blue oceans to whats the problem. It takesoff from the five forces model as the launchpad. The book the origin of the terms red and blue oceans comes from blue ocean strategy how to create uncontested market space and make the competition irrelevant. Porters five forces model and blue ocean strategy kim. Chan kim and renee mauborgne in their book titled blue ocean strategy. In this article you will learn how to make your competition irrelevant and have sales and profit.
While this came in appendix a in the book, this is a good time to cover three industries with repeated blue ocean creation. Blue ocean strategy vs michael porters five forces 2 the business world can be a very hostile environment and many strive to just make it in the industry. Jetblue airways corporation porter five forces analysis. The most important part is how to create multi layered tactical plans through use of. Jan 19, 2012 the basic strategy questions, swot analysis, porters 5 forces of competition, burgelmans strategy dynamics model, porters value chain, core competencies and resourcebased view, nonaka and takeuchis knowledge spiral, mckinseys 7s framework, scenario planning, ansoffs growth grid, bcgs product portfolio matrix, kim and mauborgnes blue. Report contains a detailed discussion of walmart porters five forces analysis. Value innovation strategy competes in an uncontested market space. To refer to the hr analogy, it is like herzbergs hygiene motivation theory which recommends building motivation factors in a job or mc gregors x and y.
Business schools teach future industry captains how to analyze an industrys determinants of profitability with porters five forces porter,1980. Why is the evidencebased methodology significant for the study of. The blue ocean strategy on the other hand is purely a strategy. Companies need to build their blue ocean strategy in the sequence of buyer utility, price, cost, and adoption. May, 2015 its not better its just different porter five forces model is used to understand the dynamics of an industry while blue ocean is a specific strategy choice a company can pursue. Five schools of thought author key concept objective michael porter competitive establish a clear positioning i. Porters five forces analysis is a framework for industry analysis and business strategy development formed by michael e. How to create uncontested market space and make competition irrelevant. What is blue ocean strategy about blue ocean strategy. Buy books, tools, case studies, and articles on leadership, strategy, innovation, and other business and management topics. A good strategist would use five forces to understand the indust. Understand what strategy actually is and learn about more than 75 core strategy tools used by business leaders. Jetblue airways corporation managers can use porter five forces to understand how the five competitive forces influence profitability and develop a strategy for enhancing jetblue airways.
Lets focus on two of the businessworlds trending marketing strategies for electronic market space today blue ocean vs. Chan kim and renee mauborgne of the blue ocean strategy institute and professors at frances insead business school and cofounders of the value innovation. Porters 5 forces of competition, burgelmans strategy dynamics model, porters value chain, core competencies and resourcebased view, nonaka and takeuchis. Its not better its just different porter five forces model is used to understand the. Jan 14, 2011 blue ocean strategy vs porters generic strategy posted by anonymous on 1142011 at 10. Successful blue ocean strategies are actually not that new its the categorizing that is. Porter five forces analysis is a strategic management tool to analyze industry and understand underlying levers of profitability in a given industry. It is being published in a recordbreaking 44 languages and is a w. Traditional competitive strategy vs blue ocean strategy. Porter s five forces model versus a blue ocean strategy essay. Blue ocean holds its ownuntil competition erodes profits from innovation, after 15 or so years. Moreover, the report contains analysis of walmarts.
This strategy revolves around searching for a business in which very few firms operate and where there is no pricing pressure. What makes blue ocean strategy better than porters five forces. A good and concise book on using strategy to unlock. Pestle is an analytical tool that identifies how various factors may. One largely unsuccessful criticism leveled against porter is the blue ocean red ocean view, in which red ocean is the same as competition to be the best, and the desirable state, blue ocean, is a strategic approach that makes competition irrelevant. Professor joe tidd identifies the weaknesses of the traditional five forces approach to strategy, and the advantages of adopting a blue ocean.
622 264 876 1028 514 452 987 601 881 467 352 1256 771 616 392 1328 872 1510 990 954 860 1210 261 936 1459 557 819 859 1487 1325 1432 396 606 79 970 1087 283 1052 1323 1457 98 810 1339 816